How to appeal
The University’s Admission, Enrolment and Academic Progress Rules (“the Rules”) contain provisions to enable students who are dissatisfied with the assessment of their academic work or progress to appeal against those decisions. These Notes are issued for the guidance of students considering submitting appeals under the Rules and are not a substitute for or a supplement to these Rules:
Result Appeal (Rule 56)
Appeal against the result of an individual item of assessment or a final unit result.
Academic Progression Status Appeal (Rule 57)
Appeal against a decision of a Faculty Board of Examiners about a student’s Academic Progression Status.
Appeal to the Student Appeals Committee (Rule 58)
Appeal against a decision made under either Rule 56 or Rule 57.
Rules 56, 57 and 58 detail the grounds on which appeals may be made and the processes and procedures that must be followed by students submitting appeals under these Rules.
If you are considering submitting an appeal it is essential that you familiarise yourself with the provisions of the Rules, which appear in their entirety on the University rules webpage.
As of September 2009 some significant changes have been made to the Rules. These Notes highlight some of those changes, together with some other relevant information. Students previously involved in the appeals process should note that the former Appeal Notes for Students have been repealed and some of the relevant provisions of those Notes are now included in the Rules.
The relevant forms which must be used in the appeals process can be found on the Forms webpage.
1. Appeal submission deadlines
Information about specific date for the submission of appeal are publicised each semester on the Appeals deadlines webpage. Note that failure to comply with these deadlines, unless variations are approved in individual cases by the Vice- Chancellor or nominee, will result in the rejection of appeals.
The deadlines for appeals are inclusive of the periods within which relevant actions must be taken. For example, under the informal discussion process required under Rule 56, the academic staff member concerned has five business days to provide the student with details of that discussion. This process must be completed within the 20 business days required before a formal appeal is lodged, so it is essential that the informal discussion be held as soon as possible after the release of the result in question.
2. Appeal submissions
Appeals may only be made on the basis of the grounds specified in the relevant Rule. The Rules require that supporting submissions address each ground of appeal and include any relevant supporting documentation, which in the case of an appeal under Rule 56 must include evidence that the informal result query stage has been completed. This will normally be demonstrated by the inclusion of an Informal Result Query form, signed by both the staff member and student concerned.
Appeals must be lodged at Student Central on the form specified, either in person or by email, post or fax. Note, however, that supporting documents cannot be lodged by email or fax as they must be original documents.
Limits are imposed by the Rules on the length of submissions and supporting documentation. Submissions that do not provide complete or adequate information or do not conform to the length requirements will be returned to the student, with written reasons for that action, and an opportunity will be provided for re-submission.
Once accepted, students will receive a receipt number for an appeal which can subsequently be referred to for information about the status of the appeal.
3. Support persons
Students attending an informal discussion of their results before deciding whether or not to submit an appeal or when attending a meeting with the Student Appeals Committee are entitled to be accompanied by another person, other than a legal practitioner. As a courtesy and to assist with meeting arrangements students who are to be supported in this way are asked to inform the staff member conducting or arranging the relevant meeting prior to that event.
Students will be provided with written confirmation of decisions and the reasons for those decisions. Notification of decisions and reasons will normally be sent to the student’s ECU email address.
5. Provisional re-enrolment
Provisional re-enrolment may be permitted pending the finalisation of an appeal against suspension or exclusion. An application for provisional enrolments must be made at the time of the submission of the appeal under Rule 57.
If an appeal made in these circumstances is unsuccessful the relevant enrolment will be cancelled. If this occurs after the published unit census date withdrawal without financial penalty may be approved. Students who are permitted to enrol provisionally cannot claim disadvantage of an academic, financial or person nature if their appeal is unsuccessful and they are required to withdraw from a provisionally enrolled unit or units.
6. External Review
Students may, in writing, request the State Ombudsman to review the manner in which their appeal was handled by the University. It should be noted that the Ombudsman will not normally investigate a complaint until all internal avenues of appeal have been completed. The Ombudsman will usually only consider if the University has followed its own policies and procedures and whether the handling of an individual case has been fair and reasonable. The Ombudsman does not make a new decision (for example, change a unit result) to replace a decision by the University. However, the Ombudsman may recommend that the University reconsider its decisions or actions.
International students intending to submit a complaint to the State Ombudsman must provide evidence to the University that they have lodged that complaint within 20 business days of receiving notice of the decision of the Student Appeals Committee not to uphold their appeal. If this evidence is not received the University must, under the provision of section 20 of the Education Services for Overseas Student Act (2002), notify the Department of Immigration and Citizenship that the student has been suspended or excluded from the University. This notification may have implications for the student’s visa status.
Contact details for the State Ombudsman are:
PO Box Z5386
St George’s Terrace
PERTH WA 6831
Got A Question? Ask Us.